Soft skills seem to be lacking in some of the IA teams. There is the art of interviewing that must be executed properly. IA can set aside time to work with other parts of the business. Audit reports are not the only communication channel.
Time to Shift the Mindset. Pulse report urges IA to focus on culture and cybersecurity response. Board members should discuss with management to ensure that there is a common understanding. There is a risk of poor vendors and that firms could suffer from reputational damage. There needs to be strong third party risk practices.
Fraud Prevention. An effective control environment can deter or minimize the occurrence of fraudulent activities. Internal controls may not always be designed to prevent fraud. There must be a strong control environment for fraud prevention. Background checks and fraud related training can be useful indeed. Whistle-blowing hotlines can be set up. A certain level of anonymity must be ensured. No one person should complete control over a whole particular process, from start to end. Monitoring activities should take place on a frequent basis.
The Call no CAE wants to receive. A strong working relationship between IA and the CIO is essential to responding quickly to a cyber incident. This is important as cyber attacks can lead to reputational damage. One can verify the controls at the vendor and get them to fill up a data security risk assessment questionnaire. IA can be the trusted advisor that an organization needs.
Collaborative Risk Management. As organizations consolidate their risk processes, IA may not be able to continue to stand alone. Risk collaboration and organizing risks are more important nowadays. There is a need to be efficient about going about this. Risk needs to be organized neatly. ERM is one way to link everything together. Auditors should be open to other ideas on organizing and mitigating risk.
The Ticking Ethical Time Bomb. The financial loss from theft was secondary to the effect on company culture. Sometimes, the most obvious issue is no the more important one. Small frauds can lead to large ones. Reinforcing identity is also very smart sometimes, as it can help with ethical reinforcement. Increasing controls should not be done as a knee-jerk reaction sort of thing.
A Matter of Trust. Attention to detail and focused effort can help IA build the relationships required to be perceived as valued advisers. IA should be given time to innovate, gain an understanding of evolving challenges and talk to people in the business regularly about the issues they face. You help to build trust if you know what the regulators or other people are doing. Sometimes, top management might even tell CAE the problems that are upcoming. Relationship building and being part of the management team is crucial. However, there is still a need to be independent even if IA is like a trusted advisor. Try to leverage on technology.
‘IA can often be forgotten if it is not part of the core team, because it is less visible than those functions that meet and talk regularly.’
‘Auditors are there to make organizations better – it is a key part of the way they can add value. Not commenting when they see a better way to do something could show a certain lack of moral courage.’
Proactive Fraud Analysis. Integrating advanced forensic data analytics capabilities can help auditors mitigate fraud risks and demonstrate returns. IA can invest in such tools as it can help in the monitoring of risk. IA should ask ‘What are the high risk accounts?’; ‘When?’; ‘Where?’ etc. IA should focus on the low-hanging fruit first. The first project undertaken should be easy. Learn to go beyond the descriptive analytics. Learn to embrace both structured and unstructured data. Communication is the key. It would be good to automate the tests and involve the end-users. Also, learn to set a realistic timetable. Keep analytics simple and intuitive – don’t include too much information in one report so it isn’t easy to understand.
Getting More from Interviews. Instead of emphasizing formalities, IA should approach each interview like a conversation. You can gain insight into the way operations work and identify gaps etc. Plan your questions beforehand and be prepared. However, the less formal it is, the more information you can find out from the interview. Try to make it a conversation. Learning about the auditees’ life can help to build rapport and build the bond. Talk to others within the auditees’ same department. The interview’s purpose should be specific, attainable and outcome oriented. Preparing for the interview helps a lot. The location matters as well. Try to open in a way that makes the auditee at ease. Try to explain the purpose and the outcome of the interview. Learn to practise effective listening. One can ask thought provoking questions that will help to elicit information. Learn to practise active listening and show positive body language such as being attentive. You can prepare questions but there is no need to follow to a list strictly. It can be difficult to build rapport. Do not try to tell the interviewee that the interview must be done to complete the audit. Have lunch with auditees once in a while. People love to hear about themselves.
‘Auditors should be curious about the way processes work, the way the organization works, and perhaps most importantly, the people who make it work. Curiosity will lead to a better understanding of the organization, better ideas for improving the organization, and a better rapport with the individuals within the organization.’
On the Hunt for Payroll Fraud. Taking a close look at payroll risks can enable IA to help their organizations save money and identify wrongdoing. Payroll fraud is more common if there is irregular workforce patterns. Payroll is usually shrouded in secrecy. Overpayment is more common than underpayment. IA can also examine to seek actual cost savings/ productivity gains. IA can adopt a helicopter overview of payroll data and the payroll process. One can compare payroll costs with other organizations. Rosters should be designed to optimize the allocation of employees to operational needs. Management welcomes findings that reveal specific wrongdoing because they provide hard-to-dispute evidence. IA can look out for certain insights and then drill further. There are many common findings. The audit fieldwork needs to be well-researched and planned.
Guardians of Integrity. IA can provide insight into corporate identity and people-related risks. For instance, IA can evaluate the ethics and organizational integrity. IA must communicate with the board and management and be the corporate conscience. Testing the effectiveness of the ethics programs can be tough. It is important to understand how an organization defines success. It is important to uphold the code of ethics: integrity; objectivity; confidentiality; competence. IA should examine incident reports too. IA must be as wise as the board, as savvy as management, and as shrews as attorneys. Stakeholder surveys could be used to understand the management and employee ethics. IIA needs to exercise fair and ethical decision making.